Is Michael Vick sorry? Or sorry he was caught?

A Dogtime editor offers her personal opinion on Michael Vick's press coverage over the last few days.

Thursday March 31st, 2011

  • Share on Facebook

America is torn apart, and it's not about health care reform, the wars overseas, the Yankees or the Red Sox. Our nation is entrenched in a hot debate over whether Michael Vick deserves a second chance.

Max_300_60minutes

I watched Michael Vick's press conference Friday and I saw his interview on "60 Minutes." I believe in second chances. But I also believe that Michael Vick had plenty of chances to do the right thing, and in each case, he failed.

I realize that Vick grew up exposed to dog fighting. It was exciting, it was part of the culture. Even cool. So maybe it's too much to expect that at some point the light would go on and he'd realize these choices are not only wrong, they're horrifically cruel. But with each new fight, each additional act of abuse or torture or killing, he chose to proceed.

Vick had another "second chance" - a chance to do the right thing when he was indicted. But instead of coming clean and being honest about the decisions he made, like a coward he lied to the judge and denied any involvement.

Bad Newz... and a sliver of good news

Still, I was heartened by some of Vick's statements in Sunday's interview. He solemnly declared his commitment to work with the Humane Society of the United States, and to use his influence to prevent more cruelty than he's inflicted. I'm eager to see his follow-through.

A few of his statements, however, left me frustrated.

"I was disgusted, you know, because of what I let happen to those animals," he said. "I could've put a stop to it. I could've walked away from it. I could've shut the whole operation down."

First, Vick needs to acknowledge the degree to which he participated in these crimes. He didn't just stand by and "let it happen"; he was not a spectator nor even a passive participant. He actively engaged in electrocution, drowning, and beating. He performed barbaric, unspeakable acts. He needs to fully take ownership of these actions - for himself and for the public.

Similarly, it's unacceptable to refer to his crimes as a "mistake" or "unnecessary" or "pointless," as he did at his press conference. Buying the wrong size battery is a mistake. An electric shaver is unnecessary. Putting jellybeans in your gas tank is pointless. Premeditated torture and killing are not comparable, and labeling them a "mistake" just adds to the perception he doesn't understand the gravity of his actions.

Who, exactly, dog fighting hurts

When James Brown asked him when he realized he'd truly done wrong, he responded, "The first day I walked into prison and they slammed that door, I knew the magnitude of the decisions that I made..." He goes on to say, "What I did, being away from my family, letting so many people down, letting myself down, not being out on the football field, being in a prison bed, in a prison bunk, writing letters home. That wasn't my life. That wasn't the way that things were supposed to be."

These statements convince me this is a man who's realized he's done wrong; proof was that he'd suddenly lost everything - his freedom, his fortune, and for a while, even his family. But I'm not anywhere near convinced he understands why his acts were wrong. His remorse was about what he lost. Michael, the wrongness is not about your squandered endorsements or your months on a prison cot. Torturing and killing others is wrong.

Finally, I don't want to hear Vick claim he loves animals any more than he wants to hear me say I'm a football fan. Admittedly, I couldn't care less about the game. But my point is, you don't have to be an animal lover to know that it's not ok to harm them. Animals are not your thing, Michael. That's fine - we all have our own passions, our own interests. But don't lie to me about yours and then expect me to take your remorse seriously.

French Poodle fajitas

This morning I watched MSNBC's "Morning Joe," where I was more infuriated by what the commentators were expressing than by anything Michael Vick has said in the last few days.

One commentator declared, "They're just dogs." As if a dog who's been beaten senseless doesn't feel pain. As if a dog who's been ravaged beyond recognition in the fighting ring doesn't feel complete terror each subsequent time he's forced to go in and endure more hell. Are you saying such acts are not that bad because they're committed against dogs? Could you stand to watch your pet experience intense prolonged suffering or die so violently?

Another guest said the reaction he got to his defense of Vick was as if he'd been caught eating French Poodle fajitas. You don't get it, man. It's about how you treat a sentient being when he's alive--whether you allow him an existence free from incessant pain, hunger, and fear, and not what you do with the body once he's dead. Don't get me wrong - I'm not advocating dogs for dinner. I'm just pointing out that years of physical and mental torture is indefensible.

Here at Dogtime, we'd like to know your reaction. Please feel free to add your comments.

DogTime newsletter
Related Content on DogTime.com

  • Philly columnist in favor of another chance for Vick

    March 31st, 2011

    <!-- -->Dear Ms. Fox, You say you don't understand why people are "dissecting every word Michael Vick says." I will try to clarify, because I can't understand why I listen, and never hear what...

  • Glimmer of hope for Michael Vick?

    March 31st, 2011

    A shot of a few protesters outside the Eagles' stadium in Philadelphia is the only mention of dogs or dog fighting in Episode 3 of BET's The Michael Vick Project. Even the snippets midway through the...

  • Let's forget Michael Vick... when there's no longer a need to remember

    March 31st, 2011

    I'm tired of Michael Vick. On Saturday, my father told me that the rest of the country was tired of the Vick story too. The majority of Americans had moved on, he said. Neither angry protesters nor...

Joey

Michael Vick served his time and is a great athlete, people need to move on and forgive

11 days ago by Joey

Anonymous User

Until you have actually seen a dog fight or seen what these dogs have endured during a fight, how can anyone speak about giving Vick a second chance. This was done over and over again to these dogs. Some of these dogs were Vicks own house pets. No matter what he did is unmentionable and maybe that is why people are so willing to forgive or just over look what he did. You have to SEE IT to get the Full Extent of it! Kim-Fort Lauderdale

over 2 years ago by Anonymous

Anonymous User

Anyone that hurts helpless animals should not be allowed to represent the Humane Society in any capacity. I am appalled that the President of the Society would allow Vick to represent the Society in any manner after what he did to those powerless dogs. Vick himself is an animal that has spent his ill gotten gains to hire a PR firm and a host of attorneys to try and clearn up his image. On top of all that, the Eagles are letting him play again - how disgusting is that?

over 2 years ago by Anonymous

Anonymous User

"The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated." Mahatma Gandhi

over 2 years ago by Anonymous

see all 90 comments →

Recent conversations on these topics

  • This ia my fist time i visit here

    about the games and software,<STRONG><A title="Office 2007 Activation Key" href="http://www.windows7activationkey.ca/">Office 2007 Activation Key</A></STRONG>, the Department will hear the two voices that can play and not play. 've never installed <STRONG><A title="Windows 7" href="http://www.windows7activationkey.ca/windows-7-activation-key">Windows 7</A></STRONG>,<STRONG><A title="Windows 7 Serial" href="http://www.windows7activationkey.us/windows-7-activation-key">Windows 7 Serial</A></STRONG>,24 No. <STRONG><A title="Windows 7" href="http://www.windows-7-key.org/">Windows 7</A></STRONG> RC 7100 came out, download and install the first time ,<STRONG><A title="Windows 7 Professional" href="http://www.windows7activationkey.ca/windows-7-activation-key/windows-7-64-bit-activation-key/discount-windows-7-professional-64-bit-activation-key.html">Windows 7 Professional</A></STRONG>, the early days but also a little busy So what did the test ,<STRONG><A title="Windows 7 Ultimate Key" href="http://www.office2007product-key.com/windows-7-product-key/windows-7-64-bit-product-key/low-windows-7-ultimate-64-bit-product-key.html">Windows 7 Ultimate Key</A></STRONG>, test a bit last night QQ games. I installed the QQ2007,<STRONG><A title="Windows 7 Home Premium" href="http://www.windows7activationkey.ca/windows-7-activation-key/windows-7-64-bit-activation-key/discount-windows-7-home-premium-64-bit-activation-key.html">Windows 7 Home Premium</A></STRONG>, open the login prompt to upgrade the game ,<STRONG><A title="Windows 7 Ultimate" href="http://www.windows7activationkey.us/windows-7-activation-key/windows-7-x64-activation-key/discount-windows-7-ultimate-x64-activation-key.html">Windows 7 Ultimate</A></STRONG>, download patches ,<STRONG><A title="Office Professional 2007" href="http://www.office2010productskey.net/office-2007-product-key/genuine-office-professional-2007-key.html">Office Professional 2007</A></STRONG>, download and install after QQ2009 Beta3. normal into the game after installation . Download joy upgrade,<STRONG><A title="Office 2010" href="http://www.key-windows-7.org/office-2010-key">Office 2010</A></STRONG>, normal install,<STRONG><A title="Windows 7 Activation Key" href="http://www.windows7-key.biz/">Windows 7 Activation Key</A></STRONG>, download enter the game. joy Landlords installed properly,<STRONG><A title="Office Enterprise 2007 Key" href="http://www.windows7activationkey.us/office-2007-activation-key/discount-microsoft-office-enterprise-2007-activation-key.html">Office Enterprise 2007 Key</A></STRONG>, enter the game normally,<STRONG><A title="Microsoft Office 2007 Key" href="http://www.office2007product-key.com/">Microsoft Office 2007 Key</A></STRONG>, no other test ,<STRONG><A title="Office Ultimate 2007" href="http://www.key-windows-7.biz/office-2007-key/discount-office-ultimate-2007-key.html">Office Ultimate 2007</A></STRONG>, I think should be able to play !

  • This ia my fist time i visit here

    about the games and software,<STRONG><A title="Office 2007 Activation Key" href="http://www.windows7activationkey.ca/">Office 2007 Activation Key</A></STRONG>, the Department will hear the two voices that can play and not play. 've never installed <STRONG><A title="Windows 7" href="http://www.windows7activationkey.ca/windows-7-activation-key">Windows 7</A></STRONG>,<STRONG><A title="Windows 7 Serial" href="http://www.windows7activationkey.us/windows-7-activation-key">Windows 7 Serial</A></STRONG>,24 No. <STRONG><A title="Windows 7" href="http://www.windows-7-key.org/">Windows 7</A></STRONG> RC 7100 came out, download and install the first time ,<STRONG><A title="Windows 7 Professional" href="http://www.windows7activationkey.ca/windows-7-activation-key/windows-7-64-bit-activation-key/discount-windows-7-professional-64-bit-activation-key.html">Windows 7 Professional</A></STRONG>, the early days but also a little busy So what did the test ,<STRONG><A title="Windows 7 Ultimate Key" href="http://www.office2007product-key.com/windows-7-product-key/windows-7-64-bit-product-key/low-windows-7-ultimate-64-bit-product-key.html">Windows 7 Ultimate Key</A></STRONG>, test a bit last night QQ games. I installed the QQ2007,<STRONG><A title="Windows 7 Home Premium" href="http://www.windows7activationkey.ca/windows-7-activation-key/windows-7-64-bit-activation-key/discount-windows-7-home-premium-64-bit-activation-key.html">Windows 7 Home Premium</A></STRONG>, open the login prompt to upgrade the game ,<STRONG><A title="Windows 7 Ultimate" href="http://www.windows7activationkey.us/windows-7-activation-key/windows-7-x64-activation-key/discount-windows-7-ultimate-x64-activation-key.html">Windows 7 Ultimate</A></STRONG>, download patches ,<STRONG><A title="Office Professional 2007" href="http://www.office2010productskey.net/office-2007-product-key/genuine-office-professional-2007-key.html">Office Professional 2007</A></STRONG>, download and install after QQ2009 Beta3. normal into the game after installation . Download joy upgrade,<STRONG><A title="Office 2010" href="http://www.key-windows-7.org/office-2010-key">Office 2010</A></STRONG>, normal install,<STRONG><A title="Windows 7 Activation Key" href="http://www.windows7-key.biz/">Windows 7 Activation Key</A></STRONG>, download enter the game. joy Landlords installed properly,<STRONG><A title="Office Enterprise 2007 Key" href="http://www.windows7activationkey.us/office-2007-activation-key/discount-microsoft-office-enterprise-2007-activation-key.html">Office Enterprise 2007 Key</A></STRONG>, enter the game normally,<STRONG><A title="Microsoft Office 2007 Key" href="http://www.office2007product-key.com/">Microsoft Office 2007 Key</A></STRONG>, no other test ,<STRONG><A title="Office Ultimate 2007" href="http://www.key-windows-7.biz/office-2007-key/discount-office-ultimate-2007-key.html">Office Ultimate 2007</A></STRONG>, I think should be able to play !

see all conversations or start your own →
AD

featured articles

see all featured content »
Help shelter dogs and puppies through Save a Dog on Facebook

Welcome to DogTime.com

DOGTIME LOGIN or SIGN UP

AD
AD