Commercial dog food

Wednesday May 27th, 2009

Question:

Are grocery-store brand dog foods as nutritious as they claim to be?

answered by Marion Nestle and Malden Nesheim

Answer:

All wet and dry commercial foods ought to promote good health, as all are supposed to meet the same AAFCO (Association of American Feed Control Officials) nutrition standards. The big commercial companies test the products to make sure they have all the nutrients they need to support growth, reproduction, and good health, but as we learned from the recent pet food recall, mistakes do happen. If you're concerned about your dog getting the right nutrients, ask your veterinarian for a recommendation.

Marion Nestle is the Paulette Goddard professor of nutrition, food studies, and public health, and professor of sociology at New York University, while Malden Nesheim is a professor of nutritional sciences and provost emeritus at Cornell University. They are the food editors of Bark magazine and are currently writing a book entitled What Pets Eat.

Tags Dog Food & Dog Nutrition

DogTime newsletter

Related Content on DogTime.com

Arthritis and the aging dog
May 30th, 2009
The signs of arthritis may be hard to spot. You might notice it takes Fido a little longer to get up in the morning and she seems to have a harder time moving around. Soon you realize that she's in...
Choosing the right dog treats
April 27th, 2009
Treats are a great way to show your dog a little extra love. These special yummies can be anything from homemade biscuits to a package from a doggy bakery, or even just a morsel of steak from your...
Your dog can have allergies, too
May 31st, 2009
Do you find yourself sneezing at a particular time of year? Does a particular material cause you to have a reaction when it comes in contact with your skin? Did you know that your dog can suffer from...

	I have been feeding my dog the generic brand (Wal Mart Old Roy) of kKibbles and Bits for 15 years now. He recently had a little surgery on his eye and the vet said his blood work was that of a 5 year old dog. He's as frisky as can be. If you ask yor vet they will want you to buy what ever brand they sell. And that will be extremely expensive. I guess if you have a sick dog maybe you shoul feed more expensive but sometimes I don't think expensive is necessarally better. Terri from Ky about 2 years ago by Anonymous
	I have been feeding my dog Snickers a mixed breed from the pound the generic (walmart Old Roy) Brand of Kibbles and Bits for 15 years. He had to have a little eye surgery last year and the vet said his blood work was like that of a 5 year old dog. Spunky Spunky If you ask your vet they are going to try to sell you what they sell which you can bet will be expensive. I also have a 14 year old Shihtzu and a 2 year old Shitzu who eat the same food. The older one has several fatty benign tumors and is losing her site a little. She is getting a little grumpy in her old age but other wise is doing fine. I guess if I had a sickly dog I might go with one of the more expensive brands but I still wouldn't know that they would help anymore. Blessins' from Ky Terri about 2 years ago by Anonymous
	I'm supposed to ask my Science Diet or Purina trained vet for nutrition advice for my dog? No thanks. If I had done that instead of switching to raw my dog wouldn't be alive right now. about 2 years ago by Anonymous
	What are 'grocery store brands'? Most stores have Eukanuba for instance; and it's advertised on this web page. They have Purina and Iams too, for instance. I don't know of any store brands. Help! over 2 years ago by Anonymous

see all 6 comments →

Recent conversations on these topics

Senior dog is losing weight
My 13 year old shepard mix is losing weight. Its really become apparent the past few days. Of course I will be bringing him to the veterinarian, but I am wondering what suggestions people have for stimulating appetite and weight gain in an older dog. As a puppy he had serious digestive problems and needed to avoid the usual culprits (corn, wheat, soy). He has been eating Canidae All Life Stages supplemented with small amounts of healthy people food almost all his life. He is a self feeder and has always maintained a healthy weight. He has taken a very low dose of phenobarb for seizures the past 5 years and Rimadyl for arthritis the past 6 months. I really like Canidae (another dog of mine lived to 17.5 years so obviously the food is good). I also have a 1 1/2 year old lab mix at home and what I feed one is likely what I will feed the other. I am considering cooking food for my old guy, giving him more of our food, or adding canned Solid Gold (the canned Canidae seems to upset his tummy---not sure why). Suggestions?
dogs LOVE these healthy dog treats!
Thanks for sharing, Jean! That does look like a good and healthy recipe for tasty treats. I'll be sure to try it for my dog. Thanks again!
Help
I feed my dogs home made food, but I occasionaly give them kibble. I used to feed Merrick dog food, but they revised their products and they now contain more fish. Lady cannot eat fish because it makes her sick. Most of the healthful brands seem to contain fish. Does anyone know of a good dog food that has little or no fish?
Picky eater
I am having trouble getting Cooper to eat. It is not that he is sick, he just hates what I feed him. The only food he will readily eat is meat, but he sometimes does not even like that. I cook for my dogs, and I have never seen a dog besides him turn his nose up to a good homecooked meal. How do I get him to love food?