Vegan dog food

Thursday May 28th, 2009

  • Share on Facebook
Question:

Have you heard any feedback on Evolution Diet dog food? It's a vegan dog food I use just to keep away all the bad stuff that comes in regular dog food. I realize dogs are obviously carnivores, but I've used this vegan dog food for my dog Chubb since I got him almost 3 years ago because it seems safer. But I'm also concerned about there being no meat-based protein in it.

answered by Christine Agro

Answer:

There's much debate about whether dogs are carnivores or omnivores. Carnivores absolutely need meat in order to survive. Omnivores can survive on either plant-based proteins or meat-based proteins. When I work with dogs, what I see clairvoyantly is that many dogs need several sources of protein in order to feel good. Their survival instincts are connected to a healthy diet. If the diet isn't complete, the nervous system sends off constant alerts that the dog is not safe. This, in turn, leads to behavioral issues. By introducing several sources, a dog's body is able to gather all the nutrients it needs to support the body and the nervous system sends out the message that everything is fine.

Normally I would say your dog needs a meat-based protein source. That being said, many beings are shifting their physical body composition and in this shift, their nutritional needs are changing to a cleaner diet more in line with a vegan diet. My advice is to keep an eye on Chubba be sure his coat stays looking healthy, his behavior is normal and his gums and eyes are doing well. Work with a holistic vet to help monitor Chubba's well-being and as long as he is doing well on the diet, then it seems fine for him. Behavioral problems including anxiety, uncertainty, excessive barking, uneven temperament, and insomnia are all indications that this diet may not be working for Chubba.

For others considering a vegan diet for their dogs, the choice should be made because it is right for your dog, not because it is your chosen lifestyle and/or philosophy. Most dogs do need meat protein, and as I said, more than one source of high-quality, meat-based protein in order to live a healthy, stable life.

Christine Agro is a renowned expert and speaker on the body's innate ability to heal through the use of natural healing modalities and energy awareness for both humans and animals. She is a graduate of the School of Natural Medicine in Boulder, Colorado, and the Clairvoyant Training Program at the Inner Connection Institute (ICI) in Denver.

Read more about Christine Agro in the DogTime expert center...
Related Content on DogTime.com
  • Arthritis and the aging dog

    March 31st, 2011

    The signs of arthritis may be hard to spot. You might notice it takes Fido a little longer to get up in the morning and she seems to have a harder time moving around. Soon you realize that she's in...

  • Choosing the right dog treats

    March 31st, 2011

    Treats are a great way to show your dog a little extra love. These special yummies can be anything from homemade biscuits to a package from a doggy bakery, or even just a morsel of steak from your...

  • Your dog can have allergies, too

    March 31st, 2011

    Do you find yourself sneezing at a particular time of year? Does a particular material cause you to have a reaction when it comes in contact with your skin? Did you know that your dog can suffer from...

Anonymous User

It´s a dificult subject to wether give vegan food to cats and dogs, but maybe instead of meat, if you gave organic eggs to cats, would that help them for the meat protein they need? I say organic eggs, as organic chickens live in a better way, and you can´t stop them laying eggs so someone needs to eat them. I think vegans might accept this, if they know where the eggs come from, a farm etc. What do you think?

over 1 year ago by Anonymous

Anonymous User

All scientific evidence points towards the fact that dogs, while not true carnivores, are opportunistic, carnivorous scavengers. Cats on the other hand are true, obligate carnivores, requiring animal protein to survive. There is a difference between a carnivorous scavenger and an omnivore though - dogs lack the dental characteristics, longer digestive tract and specific enzymes of true omnivores like humans. That is the reason why they can not digest grains and vegetables unless they are "predigested" by processing, mincing/grinding, breakdown by enzymes, or fermentation through bacteria. Once converted, they are fully available to the dog. This does, however, not mean that your dog will thrive on a diet mainly made up of poor quality grains or grain fragments, which is what most cheap foods are. Whole grains, including their entire complement of nutrients are much more valuable - and this does not only apply for a dog's diet, but for humans as well! Digestibility depends on quality and type of grain used: rice (72%) is for example more digestible than wheat (60%) or corn (54%). Dogs can absorb the digestible carbohydrates from rice almost entirely, of the other grains about 20% are not absorbed. Indigestible fiber from grains contribute to intestinal health. Sabine Contreras, Canine Care & Nutrition Consultant

over 1 year ago by Anonymous

Anonymous User

All scientific evidence points towards the fact that dogs, while not true carnivores, are opportunistic, carnivorous scavengers. Cats on the other hand are true, obligate carnivores, requiring animal protein to survive. There is a difference between a carnivorous scavenger and an omnivore though - dogs lack the dental characteristics, longer digestive tract and specific enzymes of true omnivores like humans. That is the reason why they can not digest grains and vegetables unless they are "predigested" by processing, mincing/grinding, breakdown by enzymes, or fermentation through bacteria. Once converted, they are fully available to the dog. This does, however, not mean that your dog will thrive on a diet mainly made up of poor quality grains or grain fragments, which is what most cheap foods are. Whole grains, including their entire complement of nutrients are much more valuable - and this does not only apply for a dog's diet, but for humans as well! Digestibility depends on quality and type of grain used: rice (72%) is for example more digestible than wheat (60%) or corn (54%). Dogs can absorb the digestible carbohydrates from rice almost entirely, of the other grains about 20% are not absorbed. Indigestible fiber from grains contribute to intestinal health. Sabine Contreras, Canine Care & Nutrition Consultant

over 1 year ago by Anonymous

Anonymous User

I would encourage everyone to examine the studies on dogs & cats conducted @ Cornell university. While cats are known carnivores, dogs are omnivores. Just make sure your companion is eating a well balanced diet. Multiple veg protein sources and a good vitamin supplement. I feed my 17 year old kelpie+ & 2 year old & 1 year old cattle dogs this way. I supplement with high quality vegan kibble. I make sure my dogs have loads of live foods. My family purees organic veggies...pressure cook beans etc. We rotate grains throughout the week. Believe it or not, our loves enjoy our morning muesli with us too! ....rolled oats, chopped pecans & walnuts, bananas, mango, soy yogurt and ricemilk with a splash of vanilla. If you don't offer some, prepare to have your bowl dumped in your lap while they protest! I feel commercial kibble is not needed, but we keep it around for being on the go and when friends take care of our dogs. Try Vegedog vitamins. I have also used Paul Owens (the dog whisperer)...he's the 'real' thing....his book has feeding guidelines. Unfortunately he recommends raw meat. I have used his protein ratios by simply supplementing vegan protein in place of the meat. You can get a good scale for weighing food @ a thrift store or kitchen shop and be on your way to making quality food. I agree with Christine Agro that you have to watch your companion carefully...always...as you would yourself or a child to make sure they are happy and well on ANY diet. Continuing to perpetuate the myth that dogs 'need' meat is very conservative and lacks education. Humans aren't carnivores either. We may 'crave' foods....they may taste good to ourselves and dogs, but aren't needed. Cats are the only true mammalian carnivores in our keep and I have known of many a vegan cat, though it takes a little more work. I choose to not have cat companions for this reason. I would also find it interesting that a clairvoyant would promote meat eating at all. Has Christine had clairvoyant moments with animals ready for slaughter...does she 'intuitively' sense thier desire to die? I have yet to encounter any animal that would give themselves up for food. Therefore, I feel that our lifestyle/philosophy is appropriate for our companions if it is good for ourselves.

over 2 years ago by Anonymous

Recent conversations on these topics

  • Senior dog is losing weight

    My 13 year old shepard mix is losing weight. Its really become apparent the past few days. Of course I will be bringing him to the veterinarian, but I am wondering what suggestions people have for stimulating appetite and weight gain in an older dog. As a puppy he had serious digestive problems and needed to avoid the usual culprits (corn, wheat, soy). He has been eating Canidae All Life Stages supplemented with small amounts of healthy people food almost all his life. He is a self feeder and has always maintained a healthy weight. He has taken a very low dose of phenobarb for seizures the past 5 years and Rimadyl for arthritis the past 6 months. I really like Canidae (another dog of mine lived to 17.5 years so obviously the food is good). I also have a 1 1/2 year old lab mix at home and what I feed one is likely what I will feed the other. I am considering cooking food for my old guy, giving him more of our food, or adding canned Solid Gold (the canned Canidae seems to upset his tummy---not sure why). Suggestions?

  • dogs LOVE these healthy dog treats!

    Thanks for sharing, Jean! That does look like a good and healthy recipe for tasty treats. I'll be sure to try it for my dog. Thanks again!

  • Help

    I feed my dogs home made food, but I occasionaly give them kibble. I used to feed Merrick dog food, but they revised their products and they now contain more fish. Lady cannot eat fish because it makes her sick. Most of the healthful brands seem to contain fish. Does anyone know of a good dog food that has little or no fish?

  • Picky eater

    I am having trouble getting Cooper to eat. It is not that he is sick, he just hates what I feed him. The only food he will readily eat is meat, but he sometimes does not even like that. I cook for my dogs, and I have never seen a dog besides him turn his nose up to a good homecooked meal. How do I get him to love food?

AD
Help shelter dogs and puppies through Save a Dog on Facebook

Welcome to DogTime.com

DOGTIME LOGIN or SIGN UP

AD
AD